Test Report

18 Smart speakers 04/2019

In the test, 18 smart speakers from 49 to 330 euros compete. They use the voice assistants Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant or Apple Siri. The Stiftung Warentest tests show differences in voice operation, range of functions and sound. All have shortcomings in data protection. Therefore, none of the devices gets beyond the grade "satisfactory". The best and the worst smart speakers use Amazon's Alexa.

TesterStiftung Warentest
Edition04/2019

18 Products in test

167/100

No image

Amazon Echo Plus (2. Generation) Sandstein Stoff
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
265/100
363/100

No image

Sonos One schwarz
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
461/100
461/100
461/100
760/100
760/100
958/100
958/100

No image

Google Home
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
958/100
1257/100
Harman/Kardon Allure Portable,Smart Speaker (10 h, Rechargeable battery operated)
Bluetooth speakers

Harman/Kardon Allure Portable,Smart Speaker

10 h, Rechargeable battery operated

1257/100
1257/100
Google Home Mini (Google Assistant, IFTTT)
Smart speakers
−11%
EUR44,52 was EUR49,98

Google Home Mini

Google Assistant, IFTTT

1257/100
1655/100
1655/100

No image

Sony LF-S50G schwarz
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1850/100